News RSS Feed


Ford's Future in Southampton Paul Poolton Hannah Foster Murder Trial Echo Forums


Blue Lady causes a row at the breakers

3:00pm Tuesday 12th December 2006

comment Comments (1)   Have your say »


THE famous transatlantic liner SS France, which is on the verge of being scrapped in India is at the centre of a complex legal wrangle involving international pollution laws and workers' rights.

No sooner had the liner, later known as SS Norway and now called Blue Lady, arrived in Alang, India last August than a storm of controversy broke out over her rusting bows.

Environmental and labour rights groups are celebrating victory in the latest round of arguments over whether the ship, that during the 1960s and 1970s was such a familiar sight on Southampton Water, can be broken up or not.

Ruling A provisional ruling from the Indian law courts has forbidden work to begin on cutting up the once great liner as scrapping could endanger the environment and be dangerous for the workmen as the ship contained high levels of asbestos.

The Indian Supreme Court has now asked local pollution control authorities in Gujurat to examine the present situation to see if Alang had the proper facilities to handle asbestos, oil residues and other dangerous chemicals.

Earlier in the year the Bangladeshi authorities turned the vessel away because of the amounts of asbestos, which one estimate puts at 1,240 tonnes, on-board the ship.

A committee established by the Indian Supreme Court has established "alarming indications of asbestosis and death by accidents now afflicting thousands for workers in the world's largest ship-breaking yards in India'' and that there should be "an immediate halt to the export and import of ships that have not been first pre-cleaned to remove hazards.''

More shipping stories at www.dailyecho.co.uk/shipping


Your Say YourThis is Hampshire

Gopal Krishna, says...
12:05pm Tue 26 Dec 06

"Blue lady" did not submit any document seeking permission in India for ship breaking. No such document has been either processed as per the provisions of law/ directions of the Supreme Court. India had no prior official information about this ship seeking entry in our territorial waters, none for the purpose of ship-breaking. The ship entered in the territorial waters on humanitarian grounds. After the court's order for anchoring, it was towed to United Arab Emirates docking at Fujairah and came back again thereby proving that the so-called humanitarian ground was only a ruse. Beaching was illegally allowed by GUJARAT MARITIME BOARD in CONTEMPT of COURT'S ORDER. The very entry of the ship (without prior decontamination and information) is illegal and violative of the judgment of Indian Supreme Court in the year 2003 as well as BASEL Convention/other International Conventions and the Hazardous Waste Rules of 2003. The beaching of Blue Lady itself being illegal, such illegality can not be allowed to perpetuate. Under the Indian Hazardous Wastes Rules of 2003, Schedule 8 completely bans the import of waste asbestos and wastes containing PCB/PCT. The obligation under the Stockholm Convention on Persistent Organic Pollutants which India has ratified is to prohibit entry of wastes containing PCBs, because it cannot be managed in an environmentally sound manner at present.

Comments are closed on this article.

Video News Food & Restaurant Reviews

Local Information

Enter your postcode, town or place name

House prices »   Schools »   Crime »   Hospitals »