Man's 'hell' over false rape claim (From This is Hampshire)

Is he just winding up his claim for wrongful arrest ?

del my old friend, i glad you cleared your name, i for one would not belive it from the start, i hope all those people who gave you grief say they are sorry now.

Not bad for you Southy!

Jammy Donut wrote:
Is he just winding up his claim for wrongful arrest ?

Who can blame him if he is? His DNA will now be held on record indefinitely.... even though it's been deemed illegal by the European Court of Human Rights

Jammy Donut wrote:
Is he just winding up his claim for wrongful arrest ?

I Hope he sues the police to high heaven and the copper in charge of that farce has a stain on his career ..... He could get tens of thousands once a good lawyer digs into the details of the keystone cops meets krusty the clown investigation....

****but was much shorter and lighter than the 18-stone, 6ft 3inch suspect England had described to police.****

But the Police pressed on regardless. Unbelievable stupidity.

"Mr Cummings said he had no complaints about the police and had been “gobsmacked” by his similarity to an efit of the suspect"

I can only assume some of you did not read the article, I would suggest it is the accuser who should be sued not those who investigated her complaint and by Mr Cummings own admission he was similar in appearance, I hope Mr Cummings and his family can now move on, this published statement is clearly testament to his character.

i am so glad justice was done derek is my uncle and he would of never done such a thing, his life has been turned upside down by all this and has now got to move on from it but its something that he will never forget or get over and as off all the money shes waisted on police and test all of which is tax payers money we r all thinking of u derek love susan michelle ,xxxxx

Here, There wrote:
"Mr Cummings said he had no complaints about the police and had been “gobsmacked” by his similarity to an efit of the suspect" I can only assume some of you did not read the article, I would suggest it is the accuser who should be sued not those who investigated her complaint and by Mr Cummings own admission he was similar in appearance, I hope Mr Cummings and his family can now move on, this published statement is clearly testament to his character.

ARE YOU SERIOUS !!!!
this investigation looks like it was conducted by a reception class at primary school ,,,, no, someone should be advising this guy to take those idiots to the cleaners..... his life has been damaged by negligent and incompitant police work by people who clearly did not know what the **** they were doing , we pay council tax for professionals not clowns !? get this guy some serious compensation and get some stupid , lazy and incompitant copper sacked.....

stickymcglue and jammy donut you must have small minds the guy was putting his side of the story and for having a go at the police the way the investigation was handled DO YOU KNOW ALL ABOUT THE INVESTIGATION THEN OR IS THIS HEARSAY ONCE AGAIN. As dereck said he had no problems with the police, basicly they where doing there job. If you dont know anything about the investigation write something positive. Do you know how long it takes to do the test for DNA no you dont and also to get the other evidence analyzed no you dont. I just hope you are not in his position in the future. Go and get a life. Why am I writing this the reason being I know somebody very close who was in the same situation and looking forward to at least 12 years it wasnt until it got to court and she admitted she was wrong.

espanuel wrote:
stickymcglue and jammy donut you must have small minds the guy was putting his side of the story and for having a go at the police the way the investigation was handled DO YOU KNOW ALL ABOUT THE INVESTIGATION THEN OR IS THIS HEARSAY ONCE AGAIN. As dereck said he had no problems with the police, basicly they where doing there job. If you dont know anything about the investigation write something positive. Do you know how long it takes to do the test for DNA no you dont and also to get the other evidence analyzed no you dont. I just hope you are not in his position in the future. Go and get a life. Why am I writing this the reason being I know somebody very close who was in the same situation and looking forward to at least 12 years it wasnt until it got to court and she admitted she was wrong.

he DID NOT DO IT !! THERE WAS NO EVIDENCE !! THE POLICE WERE FABRICATING A CASE AGAINST HIM !! what planet are you on ??

any decent police investigation would have looked for "proof" , "motive" , "opportunity" , "tendancy" I could go on ,,,, there was NONE of this and this man was arrested and remanded on bail on the ramblings of a mad woman with absolutely no follow up whatsoever and it seems no one bothered to examine the clothes that a child could have told them were cut and not torn....... I am staggered that these clowns may get away with this ,,,, this investigation was a total and utter shambles and if this guy does not sue then the world has gone completely mad , the police have no right to arrest people on a whim with random parameters , this is 2010 UK , not 1950s East Germany

stickymcglue wrote:

espanuel wrote: stickymcglue and jammy donut you must have small minds the guy was putting his side of the story and for having a go at the police the way the investigation was handled DO YOU KNOW ALL ABOUT THE INVESTIGATION THEN OR IS THIS HEARSAY ONCE AGAIN. As dereck said he had no problems with the police, basicly they where doing there job. If you dont know anything about the investigation write something positive. Do you know how long it takes to do the test for DNA no you dont and also to get the other evidence analyzed no you dont. I just hope you are not in his position in the future. Go and get a life. Why am I writing this the reason being I know somebody very close who was in the same situation and looking forward to at least 12 years it wasnt until it got to court and she admitted she was wrong.

he DID NOT DO IT !! THERE WAS NO EVIDENCE !! THE POLICE WERE FABRICATING A CASE AGAINST HIM !! what planet are you on ?? any decent police investigation would have looked for "proof" , "motive" , "opportunity" , "tendancy" I could go on ,,,, there was NONE of this and this man was arrested and remanded on bail on the ramblings of a mad woman with absolutely no follow up whatsoever and it seems no one bothered to examine the clothes that a child could have told them were cut and not torn....... I am staggered that these clowns may get away with this ,,,, this investigation was a total and utter shambles and if this guy does not sue then the world has gone completely mad , the police have no right to arrest people on a whim with random parameters , this is 2010 UK , not 1950s East Germany

You're a moron!

SotonLad wrote:

stickymcglue wrote:

espanuel wrote: stickymcglue and jammy donut you must have small minds the guy was putting his side of the story and for having a go at the police the way the investigation was handled DO YOU KNOW ALL ABOUT THE INVESTIGATION THEN OR IS THIS HEARSAY ONCE AGAIN. As dereck said he had no problems with the police, basicly they where doing there job. If you dont know anything about the investigation write something positive. Do you know how long it takes to do the test for DNA no you dont and also to get the other evidence analyzed no you dont. I just hope you are not in his position in the future. Go and get a life. Why am I writing this the reason being I know somebody very close who was in the same situation and looking forward to at least 12 years it wasnt until it got to court and she admitted she was wrong.

he DID NOT DO IT !! THERE WAS NO EVIDENCE !! THE POLICE WERE FABRICATING A CASE AGAINST HIM !! what planet are you on ?? any decent police investigation would have looked for "proof" , "motive" , "opportunity" , "tendancy" I could go on ,,,, there was NONE of this and this man was arrested and remanded on bail on the ramblings of a mad woman with absolutely no follow up whatsoever and it seems no one bothered to examine the clothes that a child could have told them were cut and not torn....... I am staggered that these clowns may get away with this ,,,, this investigation was a total and utter shambles and if this guy does not sue then the world has gone completely mad , the police have no right to arrest people on a whim with random parameters , this is 2010 UK , not 1950s East Germany

You're a moron!

you should join hampshire police ,,,,, you have the vocabulary sorted and the rational for your arguments prefected ,,, you would fit in !!! LOL !!!

FFS! the guy had no problem with police. As I keep saying rape cases are dealt with with 'belief' from the victim because there are often no witnesses. If this was your daughter, and police put up an e-fit and a man was arrested I bet you'd be baying for his blood and accuse the police of bodging the investigation then when he was released. YOu don't have the full facts of the investigation so how you can 'judge' the police on their quality of investigation is beyond me. They discovered that she wasn't telling the truth. Some people are good liars, and are convincing! The fact is that this girl as it fault, not the police who did everything in their power to try and investigate it. The poor guy concerned doesn't blame the police and even wants his accuser to get help. Sometimes it's just mindless to blame police without thinking about the wider issue of how rapes are dealt with and WHY!

this girl did every woman who has ever been raped a grave disservice and as restorative justice she should be made to meet real life victims. It would certainly make her think twice.

As for Mr Cummings still not being beleived, I hope those vacuous idiots in his local bars hang their heads in shame!

Thankyou freemantelgirl2. It seems everybody wants to knock somebody when they are trying to do there job even if isnt to the readers satisfaction. As you say basiclly hope it never happens to them or there family. Happy New Year.

freemantlegirl2 wrote:
FFS! the guy had no problem with police. As I keep saying rape cases are dealt with with 'belief' from the victim because there are often no witnesses. If this was your daughter, and police put up an e-fit and a man was arrested I bet you'd be baying for his blood and accuse the police of bodging the investigation then when he was released. YOu don't have the full facts of the investigation so how you can 'judge' the police on their quality of investigation is beyond me. They discovered that she wasn't telling the truth. Some people are good liars, and are convincing! The fact is that this girl as it fault, not the police who did everything in their power to try and investigate it. The poor guy concerned doesn't blame the police and even wants his accuser to get help. Sometimes it's just mindless to blame police without thinking about the wider issue of how rapes are dealt with and WHY! this girl did every woman who has ever been raped a grave disservice and as restorative justice she should be made to meet real life victims. It would certainly make her think twice. As for Mr Cummings still not being beleived, I hope those vacuous idiots in his local bars hang their heads in shame!

Well said! IF he had been a rapist, tried and found guilty, I wonder what sentence he would have received!
My betting is that it would have been considerably longer than what Miss England has been given plus he would have been added to the sex-offenders list and the victim's name would NOT have been made public!
I cannot understand why Mr Cummings' name was made public, especially as he had not been charged with any offence.

his name had to be cleared as ppl still had it in there heads he was guilty and could not go to the pubs he loves cus all the looks he was given thats why hes cleared his name now he an walk in there with his head held hight you go derek ????????????//

Big Mac wrote:
Not bad for you Southy!

well mac if you had noticed i stayed away from the last few news reports on this, knowing what crap is spouted out from the idiots that you get on here, and those bigger idiots who like to use multi names and clone other people names.