When news happens, text SDE and your photos or videos to 80360. Or contact us by email and phone.
11:10am Sunday 12th February 2012 in News By Simon Moss
COMMENTS about jobseekers by Basingstoke MP Maria Miller have riled an unemployed former deputy borough mayor.
Phil Heath, who was the deputy mayor of Basingstoke and Deane between 2009 and 2011, has spent more than six months trying to find work.
He said he is disgusted with remarks made by Mrs Miller, a Minister in the Department for Work and Pensions, on BBC Radio 5 Live last Sunday evening, where she said there are 400,000 jobs at any one point in job centres.
She told the Pienaar’s Politics programme: “I was up in the Wirral on Friday, talking to one of our local job centres there, and there isn’t a shortage of jobs. What there can be is a lack of an appetite for some of the jobs that are available.”
The remarks disgusted Mr Heath (pictured), formerly a long-standing Tory councillor, who worked as a consultant in the building industry before being laid off nearly eight months ago. He said Mrs Miller is “out of touch”.
“I am absolutely appalled,” he told The Gazette. “If you go to the job centre in Basingstoke and put in a search, you get four local jobs, and then others in places like Glasgow.
“She says there is a lack of skills. I have applied for 40 jobs including working in an office, driving a van and plenty of others that I am well qualified for. There is not a lack of skills – it just boils down to the fact that there are 40 to 50 people applying for each job.”
Mr Heath was expelled from the Conservative party in 2008. He then served as a member of the Basingstoke First Community Party.
Mrs Miller told The Gazette she felt her comments had been taken in isolation rather than within the context of the radio show’s discussion, which was looking at how to get people on disability benefits, who can work, back into jobs.
“The important thing is that it is not just about the number of jobs that are available. It is about making sure people who are about to take that jump into employment know they cannot be better off by being out of work.”
Comments(70)
BugBear
says...
2:58pm Sun 12 Feb 12
jondave wrote:I'm pretty sure I'm not what could be classed a scrounger. Having worked hard all my life in managerial positions, I unfortunately found myself out of work and having to sign on at the Job Centre every two weeks, if only to get my NI stamp paid. The facts are there are jobs on offer in the Job Centre but they are mostly for the bare minimum wage, that's the good ones, the bulk of the others offer no guarantee at all. I'm as guilty as anyone, just as you are in your post of thinking things are not as bad as they appear. I always said, when I was working, if I ever found myself out of work, I would do anything rather than sit at home doing nothing. Then reality came along and things are not as easy as you would expect and the fact is hundreds of people are chasing the same poorly paid one job, so really you stand very little chance of being successful. As for Marie Miller, I think she is quite possibly the worse MP Basingstoke has ever had and I say that as someone who until quite recently voted Conservative all their life. She cannot be trusted to keep to her principles, in fact I don't believe she has any instead her eye is more on promotion of her chosen political career that serving us or in fact in her present position, the country. The sooner she is gone the better for all of us.
Hmmm. I have just gone to the Direct.gov website which the Job Centre uses and searched for all jobs in a 15 mile radius of Basingstoke. (15 miles is the default search and a not unreasonable distance) 250 results. I suggest Mr Heath is talking from a oriface other than that on his face...
P Heath
says...
3:44pm Sun 12 Feb 12
P Heath
says...
3:53pm Sun 12 Feb 12
jondave
says...
6:08pm Sun 12 Feb 12
P Heath wrote:Who has got a made up name Mr Heath? My user name reflects my real name thanks. So what are you doing to make yourself employable? Training? Education? I am very surprised you cannot get another job in building industry as that industry as clearly active. Self employment an option? I know a lot of people made redundant who have set up in business. Seems to be a side to this story that is missing!
250 jobs for 10 times the number in Basingstoke looking for work.
Unfortunately when you look deeper the area covered includes not just Basingstoke, Reading, Newbury, Southampton oh and Glasgow, Manchester I could go on.
400,000 across the uk unemployment 8% of population maths are not Marias strong point.
I love those who comment and hide behind a made up name when I speak from any oriface at least people know who I am.
keith O'Reilly
says...
6:45pm Sun 12 Feb 12
keith O'Reilly
says...
6:50pm Sun 12 Feb 12
P Heath
says...
8:09pm Sun 12 Feb 12
P Heath
says...
8:10pm Sun 12 Feb 12
stevemac1970
says...
10:22pm Sun 12 Feb 12
keith O'Reilly
says...
7:09am Mon 13 Feb 12
jondave
says...
8:22am Mon 13 Feb 12
P Heath wrote:Ummm, I take it you do not believe people should have middle names then? I would love to try and answer your post, but the standard of English in it is so staggeringly appalling, I am struggling to actually comprehend large parts of your post!! So what if there are 400,000 jobs on the Job Centre - that is not the only source of jobs available. Frankly your posts merely back up the smug grin in your photo on the story. Now, stop posting useless rubbish on an internet noticeboard and spend your time finding a job.
So jondave reflects your name! Mr Jon Dave probably not. Insults from both of you must have pricked your ill informed views I am pursuing self employment your assumptions are outstanding I apply for jobs available. No answer to the maths 400,000 jobs many out of date for millions out of work nationally 250 jobs in basingstoke most out of date for at least 10 times that number chasing them many like chefs, surveyors engineers highly skilled with a minimum of 2 years training no good for jobs now. Do you agree with Mrs Miller if you do appy to meet you and introduce you to the unemployed I meet not those who have no skills or workshy but young people with good GCSE, ALevel or Degree passes and people like me in their 50's to "assume" makes an **** out of you and me Icheck facts so that leaves you Mr Dave and Keith .
P Heath
says...
12:20pm Mon 13 Feb 12
P Heath
says...
12:20pm Mon 13 Feb 12
jondave
says...
1:03pm Mon 13 Feb 12
Mighty Antar
says...
1:47pm Mon 13 Feb 12
keith O'Reilly wrote:It's Maria Miller and this government that doesn't get it. The Tory economic plan isn't working. In the Euro area (where the right wing media have focussed so much attention) growth is increasing. In the UK it's shrinking. Maria Miller, safely employed and non-disabled has no concept of what it's like to be disabled and unemployed in a country where the government and the press continually frames you as a lazy, work-shy drain on resources. Instead of showing her ineptitude at maths, and pointing out the bleeding obvious (most people would rather be in work earning a decent living than out of it struggling on a pittance) she should look at why her government's economic plans are failing and thereby decreasing the number of opportunities available to both able and disabled people.
You just don't get it, do you?
1. Not every job gets advertised at the Jobcentre. There is no law that says an employer has to use them. Basing the availability of employment on dividing the registered unemployed (don't get me started on the 'hidden' unemployed) by the number of jobs advertised at a Jobcentre doesn’t make good sense but good headlines.
2. Unless you are seeking employment as a self opinionated Colonel Blimp type character, why on earth go to a newspaper? What good would it do? Certainly a publicity seeking has-been or never-was would find this useful but a serious jobseeker should be using their talents to apply for job, not go bleating to the press.
3. If you are pursuing self employment I'm sure the Jobcentre can help you with that as well.
4. Mr. P. Health, I sincerely hope you find employment. It will be good for your wallet, good for your head and hopefully will give you something constructive to do with your time.
stevemac1970
says...
2:23pm Mon 13 Feb 12
keith O'Reilly wrote:Well Mr O'Reilly perhaps you can explain why the minister concerned complains that disabled people are lacking in skills yet when given the chance says "no" to helping disabled get the skills.
You just don't get it, do you? 1. Not every job gets advertised at the Jobcentre. There is no law that says an employer has to use them. Basing the availability of employment on dividing the registered unemployed (don't get me started on the 'hidden' unemployed) by the number of jobs advertised at a Jobcentre doesn’t make good sense but good headlines. 2. Unless you are seeking employment as a self opinionated Colonel Blimp type character, why on earth go to a newspaper? What good would it do? Certainly a publicity seeking has-been or never-was would find this useful but a serious jobseeker should be using their talents to apply for job, not go bleating to the press. 3. If you are pursuing self employment I'm sure the Jobcentre can help you with that as well. 4. Mr. P. Health, I sincerely hope you find employment. It will be good for your wallet, good for your head and hopefully will give you something constructive to do with your time.
P Heath
says...
11:32am Tue 14 Feb 12
robertspet8
says...
11:58am Tue 14 Feb 12
robertspet8
says...
12:01pm Tue 14 Feb 12
The _right_stuff
says...
12:58pm Tue 14 Feb 12
stevemac1970
says...
1:17pm Tue 14 Feb 12
P Heath wrote:So true.
Those who hide behind a false identity and throw insults are sad people if you believe in what you say stand up proudly and be brave. So it cost me a lot malicous attacks, bankruptcy loss of home and health.. I still keep my honesty and integrity I still fight for the disadvantaged and against politicians that do not serve the people. And I feel good about me.
Best_Name_Ever
says...
1:50pm Tue 14 Feb 12
stevemac1970 wrote:This seems to be self publicity for a bitter ex councillor, rather than a daring exclusive. Sad really.
P Heath wrote: Those who hide behind a false identity and throw insults are sad people if you believe in what you say stand up proudly and be brave. So it cost me a lot malicous attacks, bankruptcy loss of home and health.. I still keep my honesty and integrity I still fight for the disadvantaged and against politicians that do not serve the people. And I feel good about me.So true. I would go do far as to say, I have just 2 complaints about P.Heath 1. He should still be a borough cllr. And 2. People still ring me to ask if he can get involved in their issues because they don't trust the Tories running the council.
Best_Name_Ever
says...
1:50pm Tue 14 Feb 12
stevemac1970 wrote:This seems to be self publicity for a bitter ex councillor, rather than a daring exclusive. Sad really.
P Heath wrote: Those who hide behind a false identity and throw insults are sad people if you believe in what you say stand up proudly and be brave. So it cost me a lot malicous attacks, bankruptcy loss of home and health.. I still keep my honesty and integrity I still fight for the disadvantaged and against politicians that do not serve the people. And I feel good about me.So true. I would go do far as to say, I have just 2 complaints about P.Heath 1. He should still be a borough cllr. And 2. People still ring me to ask if he can get involved in their issues because they don't trust the Tories running the council.
P Heath
says...
2:02pm Tue 14 Feb 12
robertspet8
says...
4:44pm Tue 14 Feb 12
P Heath wrote:It is pointless even responding to insults Phil. These people only use insults because they are either incapable or unwilling to address the issues.
Again insults from an unknown seen and heard much better do I care only about people not words.
MediaVoice
says...
4:48pm Tue 14 Feb 12
P Heath
says...
5:05pm Tue 14 Feb 12
MediaVoice
says...
7:01pm Tue 14 Feb 12
P Heath
says...
7:23pm Tue 14 Feb 12
bonniecat
says...
9:41pm Tue 14 Feb 12
bonniecat
says...
9:47pm Tue 14 Feb 12
bonniecat
says...
9:48pm Tue 14 Feb 12
Best_Name_Ever
says...
7:59am Wed 15 Feb 12
MediaVoice
says...
8:44am Wed 15 Feb 12
P Heath
says...
2:36pm Wed 15 Feb 12
MediaVoice
says...
6:16pm Wed 15 Feb 12
The _right_stuff
says...
8:44pm Wed 15 Feb 12
P Heath
says...
10:47am Thu 16 Feb 12
GC31
says...
1:33pm Thu 16 Feb 12
P Heath
says...
2:00pm Thu 16 Feb 12
jondave
says...
3:06pm Thu 16 Feb 12
P Heath wrote:Funny how you only criticise "false names" when that individual is negative towards you! Seriously though, your written English is so substandard, perhaps there ARE real reasons why you are not finding work!
No idea he/she hides behind a false name but he/she needs help to get over this pain
MediaVoice
says...
3:37pm Thu 16 Feb 12
P Heath
says...
4:18pm Thu 16 Feb 12
jondave
says...
8:07am Fri 17 Feb 12
P Heath wrote:Well, my name isn't false. For some reason, your mental challenges seem to have issues with that. Then again, you seem to have issues full stop! If your abysmal English hasn't killed your hopes of employment, blubbing to the newpapers and then writing comments that clearly identify you by using your real name CERTAINLY has. It would be funny if it didn't mean you are going to be a burden on my taxes until you die! For what it is worth, my maths skills are not my strength - luckily I have made career choices that have ensured this isn't a constraint.
I criticise all false names please do not feel persecuted your observations are valid maths is my strong point perhaps you can help my english and I can help oth your mental anguish see we are almost friends is that not nice in these difficult times, Nero any good for you? both?
MediaVoice
says...
1:00pm Fri 17 Feb 12
Jonty11
says...
1:29pm Fri 17 Feb 12
MediaVoice
says...
2:41pm Fri 17 Feb 12
stevemac1970
says...
3:43pm Fri 17 Feb 12
Best_Name_Ever wrote:Oh you poor thing. If that's really what you think then it shows your lack of understanding of the real world of Basingstoke conservatives. Phil is rightly upset, and if you are a conservative you will know what really went on as do the rest of us. Just remember that it was 2 senior Basingstoke Tories who called a former senior officer in the British armed forces, someone who took a bullet while fighting for his country, a traitor.... If they can say things like that and get away with, they will believe they can say what they want. Anyone prepared to defend people who say things like that needs to consider their position very carefully. Behaviour like these people have displayed in recent years is inexcusable and I believe they should be blocked from holding any form of political office. Perhaps with people that understand real life in politics, Basingstoke, and indeed the country, would be a better place to live.
stevemac1970 wrote:This seems to be self publicity for a bitter ex councillor, rather than a daring exclusive. Sad really.P Heath wrote: Those who hide behind a false identity and throw insults are sad people if you believe in what you say stand up proudly and be brave. So it cost me a lot malicous attacks, bankruptcy loss of home and health.. I still keep my honesty and integrity I still fight for the disadvantaged and against politicians that do not serve the people. And I feel good about me.So true. I would go do far as to say, I have just 2 complaints about P.Heath 1. He should still be a borough cllr. And 2. People still ring me to ask if he can get involved in their issues because they don't trust the Tories running the council.
THX 1138
says...
4:10pm Fri 17 Feb 12
P Heath
says...
6:55pm Fri 17 Feb 12
MediaVoice
says...
7:14pm Fri 17 Feb 12
The _right_stuff
says...
8:08pm Fri 17 Feb 12
P Heath
says...
9:00pm Fri 17 Feb 12
P Heath
says...
9:05pm Fri 17 Feb 12
cllr Andrew McCormick
says...
12:01am Sat 18 Feb 12
bubble_pie
says...
9:09pm Sat 18 Feb 12
MediaVoice
says...
1:15pm Sun 19 Feb 12
P Heath
says...
7:56pm Sun 19 Feb 12
MediaVoice
says...
8:14am Mon 20 Feb 12
P Heath
says...
9:59am Mon 20 Feb 12
MediaVoice
says...
10:31am Mon 20 Feb 12
iamapayne
says...
5:04pm Mon 20 Feb 12
P Heath
says...
10:35pm Mon 20 Feb 12
MediaVoice
says...
7:11am Tue 21 Feb 12
P Heath
says...
12:37pm Tue 21 Feb 12
MediaVoice
says...
3:23pm Tue 21 Feb 12
robertspet8
says...
2:14pm Wed 22 Feb 12
iamapayne wrote:You touch on some very interesting issues Brian (is that your real name? I really don't care!).
Phil why you need to know real names and why you rude to people if i said my name is brian payne what that mean to you Jon i think you are bad man to say he is a liar and to be rude to him stevemac1970 why you interested you live in scotland robertspet8 why you interested you live in twickenham sorry for my english i live here 10 years my helper has just gone home
MediaVoice
says...
4:14pm Wed 22 Feb 12
popleyrebel2
says...
8:44pm Thu 23 Feb 12
Search for Jobs
Search Now »
Find the right person for you
Search Now »
Search for Homes
Search Now »
Search for Cars
Search Now »
jondave says...
12:06pm Sun 12 Feb 12